Deals open & closed at the same time

Avatar
acealert
  • updated
  • Not a bug

Hi, so I did backtest with all signals off. With this condition, EA will open on 1st tick and do the martingale

All went fine, but for this one (27 June 2016 - 05 July 2016, but I only sent report for 27 June 2016 as same case and for simplicity)

The graphic show no equity drawdown at all

Image 1286

And the deals were closed without TP and at the same time when deals were opened. Almost 90%+ I guess all deals have behavior like this

Image 1288

This is other deals that performed normally (closed with TP)

Image 1289

I used V2.29. All required for investigation on file below (report, .ini, .set)

Error.rar

Replies 8
Avatar
0
Andrey Khatimlianskyi
  • Under review

It seems like bad ticks data on FBS-Demo. You can check it by Ctrl+U — Ticks tab.

Try to test on another broker.

Avatar
0
Andrey Khatimlianskyi

And THANK YOU for such a detailed bug-report )

Avatar
1
acealert
Quote from Andrey Khatimlianskyi

It seems like bad ticks data on FBS-Demo. You can check it by Ctrl+U — Ticks tab.

Try to test on another broker.

What I need to know from ticks tab? I'll check it later

Anyway, I did re-test with your ICM, seems you're right,, bad ticks data from FBS-Demo

I''ll do my best to send the report here when I already have free time

Avatar
0
acealert
Quote from Andrey Khatimlianskyi

And THANK YOU for such a detailed bug-report )

You're welcome :D

Avatar
1
acealert
Quote from acealert

What I need to know from ticks tab? I'll check it later

Anyway, I did re-test with your ICM, seems you're right,, bad ticks data from FBS-Demo

I''ll do my best to send the report here when I already have free time

ICM Result

Seems no problem (attached)

ICM.rar


And below is SS for FBS-Demo ticks data

EURUSD_201606270000_201606272359.csv

At last, SS from ICM ticks data

EURUSD_201606270001_201606272359.csv

Avatar
0
Andrey Khatimlianskyi
And below is SS for FBS-Demo ticks data

No bids, no asks. I have no idea how tester should execute orders with such ticks history.

Check please 2016.06.27 02:49:00 (+/- 1 second)

Avatar
0
acealert
Quote from Andrey Khatimlianskyi
And below is SS for FBS-Demo ticks data

No bids, no asks. I have no idea how tester should execute orders with such ticks history.

Check please 2016.06.27 02:49:00 (+/- 1 second)

Really? No tick data on 2016.06.27 02:49:00

SMH


So we cannot do anything on these, beside:

1. Skip that date for backtest

2. Move on to test live account/different broker

Avatar
0
Andrey Khatimlianskyi
  • Not a bug

Yep, don't test on such bad history. You'll have random results.