Metatrader Tester and Visual diferent result

Avatar
  • updated
  • Fixed

This is the first time I see it, that the result using Metatrader 5 build 4275, in "visual" mode gives me different tests if it is not visual.

I don't know where the problem could be, CP or Metatrader

Metatrader_5_build_4275.ini

Image 5883

Image 5884

CP v2.58

Image 5885

How would you rate the customer service you received?

Satisfaction mark by Ulises Cune 10 months ago

Thanks for de bug fixed

Add a comment about quality of support you received (optional):

Avatar
0
Andrey Khatimlianskyi
  • Started
Quote from Ulises Cune

Hi Andrey, I'm back with this error again after a long time and the release of MT5. The same thing is happening to me. It works fine with Visual Tester, but not without it. I'll give you details.

I have tested it with these 2 versions of MT5

Image 6014

Image 6016

No visual Mode: (Bug/Problem/Incorrect)

Image 6015

Image 6017

Here is the mistake, you should not open 2 trades at the same time. Here you open a buy and a sell at the same time. (17:00)

I have it set up as follows

Traders open on every new candle

Image 6023

Hedge is disabled (A buy and a sell should not be opened at the same time.)

Image 6020

Adx opens martingale if Drawdown is >=20%

Image 6022

Image 6021


Inifile:

XAUUSD_ADX_NEWS.ini

Logs:

20240807_NoVisual.zip

20240807-Visual.zip

CustomIndy:

Moving Average Crossover.ex5

With Visual Tester: (Correct)

Image 6018

Image 6019

Open a single buy trade, is correct.

Whatever you need, let me know.

Thanks for the detailed report!

The bug is -- it updates the list of opened trades if Allow hedge is true or GUI is enabled. That's why it works fine in visual mode.

I'll fix this now.

Avatar
0
Ulises Cune

Ahh, I think I know why CP worked like this. The News gives 2 signals at the same time, buy and sell, you have to complement it with another signal so that it opens in the right direction. I think that's how CP worked, I think I read it somewhere.

Add "BigCandle" to give direction (buy/sell) to the trade.

No Visual Mode:

Image 6028


To give direction to the trade.

Image 6029


Sorry Andrey for the report bug.

Avatar
0
Ulises Cune

Hi Andrey, I'm back with this error again after a long time and the release of MT5. The same thing is happening to me. It works fine with Visual Tester, but not without it. I'll give you details.

I have tested it with these 2 versions of MT5

Image 6014

Image 6016

No visual Mode: (Bug/Problem/Incorrect)

Image 6015

Image 6017

Here is the mistake, you should not open 2 trades at the same time. Here you open a buy and a sell at the same time. (17:00)

I have it set up as follows

Traders open on every new candle

Image 6023

Hedge is disabled (A buy and a sell should not be opened at the same time.)

Image 6020

Adx opens martingale if Drawdown is >=20%

Image 6022

Image 6021


Inifile:

XAUUSD_ADX_NEWS.ini

Logs:

20240807_NoVisual.zip

20240807-Visual.zip

CustomIndy:

Moving Average Crossover.ex5

With Visual Tester: (Correct)

Image 6018

Image 6019

Open a single buy trade, is correct.

Whatever you need, let me know.

Avatar
0
Orion Pax

I think the error is caused by MetaTrader. For example, when I tested the last month, there was a profit of 450 dollars, and when I tested the last year, there was a profit of 450 dollars. I think the backtest results of the meta should not be trusted too much.

Avatar
0
Andrey Khatimlianskyi

Visual:

Image 5905

Avatar
0
Andrey Khatimlianskyi

Ulises, I have only 2 buy trades with this ini. And they are the same in visual/non-visual mode:

Image 5904


MT5 is also 4275

Avatar
2
Sai Pratap

Hi Ulises,

I have also faced such issue earlier. That was due to a bug in TDI indicator, giving one signal(sell) when using Visual tester but other signal(neutral) when using tester. .

Let me see ur case.

Avatar
1
Andrey Khatimlianskyi
  • Under review

Thanks, I'll check.