Avatar
Andrey Khatimlianskyi
  • Under review

Thanks for sharing!

But it can't pass 2019 without SL:

Avatar
john ital

hi Andrey,

i ran the same test during the same period and got the below results showing the same as Sergio?

i also made a slight change to the set and got the Max DD down to 47%.

i have done the bellow comparison charts of the original Sergio set , my modified set and the current live set for review showing that if we can confirm testing results and that the test results are not because of over-fitting then we could have a great set on our hands.

i also ran a post optimization period test 07/01/2019 to 31/07/2020 (this period was confirmed by sergio)

im not sure why you got different results?





Avatar
Kishan Bhatt

Hi, 

Can you all post which broker it is with? I get the same issues where a set file looks great then looks horrific on another broker. 

Avatar
Kishan Bhatt

A note on drawdown, I am noticing that around march of this year seems to kill the fx market in general. I personally think this year is a great stress test for any set file, given the impact of covid in general on the wider economy. So whilst 47% looks awful at first glance, given that lots of currencies were hit very hard, this actually doesn't seem too bad to me. 

Unless someones who is more experienced than me would like to say otherwise. 

Avatar
john ital
Quote from Kishan Bhatt

Hi, 

Can you all post which broker it is with? I get the same issues where a set file looks great then looks horrific on another broker. 

Hi Kishan 

It was with ic markets 

Avatar
IntheDark

In Pepperstone (leverage 1:30 because the stupid ESMA regulation) I also hit SL in 2019...

Avatar
Andrey Khatimlianskyi
  • Checked

Already tested it on IC and have the same results. So, it can be used.

But I think we should focus on non-martingale settings to make our trading safer.

Sergio, thanks for your set!

Avatar
Kishan Bhatt

Hello

Confirmed test with Admiral markets, vs the default, this improves trading accuracy by over 10%! with a huge improvement on the balance for the time period of Jan-Aug 2020. Will use this as my new set file for a demo account I am testing no Admiral. But  given the martingdale nature of the strategy, I can't! 

ReportTester-40938142.xlsx

Avatar
Andrey Khatimlianskyi
  • Checked

Updated original set attached to the first post.

The little difference between trades because of Identify Trend. In 2.19 it was fixed a bit:


And.... crashes in 2020: